Beach Hotels in Shelter Island, NY

Check In
Check Out
Guests
Rooms
1

Adults
2
Children
0

1 - 2 of 2 Hotel Results

Photo of The Pridwin Hotel in Shelter Island, NY

The Pridwin Hotel

(4.4)

$304 + / night

Located in Shelter Island, NY

View on Map
Photo of Family Beach House and Cottage in Shelter Island, NY

Family Beach House and Cottage

(5)

$275 + / night

Located in Shelter Island, NY

View on Map

Other Beach Hotels Near Shelter Island, NY

These hotels are in nearby towns or cities but still close to Shelter Island.

ZaLo Manor House Lakefront hot tub pets

(0)

$275 + / night

Located in Peru, NY — 0.1 mi from Shelter Island

Modern one bedroom apartment

(0)

$249 + / night

Located in Princes Bay, NY — 0.1 mi from Shelter Island

Lakefront Gloversville Home with Beach and Dock!

(0)

$395 + / night

Located in Broadalbin, NY — 0.1 mi from Shelter Island

Lake Front Home Near Peek'n Peak

(0)

$275 + / night

Located in Findley Lake, NY — 0.1 mi from Shelter Island

ZaLo House Waterline cabin with Hot Tub Pets

(0)

$166 + / night

Located in Peru, NY — 0.1 mi from Shelter Island

New Oceanfront 4BR 4BA Sleeps 20 With Game Room

(0)

$304 + / night

Located in New York, NY — 0.1 mi from Shelter Island

The Elms Waterfront Cottages

(0)

$275 + / night

Located in Lake Luzerne, NY — 0.1 mi from Shelter Island

Shelter Island Retreat with Outdoor Pool!

(4.2)

$1,122 + / night

Located in Shelter Island Heights, NY — 0.3 mi from Shelter Island

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

(4.5)

$200 + / night

Located in Greenport, NY — 1.7 mi from Shelter Island

Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast

(4.8)

$304 + / night

Located in Greenport, NY — 2.1 mi from Shelter Island

Traveling to Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, boasts stunning beach access and a tranquil ambiance that sets it apart from other beach destinations. With its scenic shoreline featuring sandy beaches, picturesque coves, and coastal bluffs, visitors can indulge in sun-soaked days and breathtaking sunsets along the waterfront. The island's natural surroundings offer a wealth of outdoor activities, including hiking along the beachfront trails of Mashomack Preserve and kayaking in the serene waters of Coecles Harbor. Local culture thrives here, highlighted by seasonal festivals and a laid-back vibe, making it a perfect escape for those looking to unwind. Ideal for a summer getaway, Shelter Island enjoys warm temperatures and a gentle sea breeze, inviting beachgoers from late spring through early fall. With easy access via ferry services from both Long Island and Connecticut, this hidden gem offers a unique blend of relaxation and adventure, ensuring an unforgettable beach vacation.

Traveler Questions for Shelter Island Hotels

Popular spots to visit when you're in Shelter Island include South Harbor Park, Reichert Family Community Playground, Orient Beach State Park, East End Seaport Museum, Railroad Museum Of Long Island.
The closest airports to Shelter Island are Town of East Hampton Airport, Francis S. Gabreski Airport, Groton–New London Airport.
Nearby places to eat in Shelter Island include Restaurant Osprey Bar & Lounge, Restaurant Eccentric Bagel, Restaurant Isola.